How to Choose the Best Realtor in Chicago: 10 Questions
Looking for the best realtor in Chicago? Ask these 10 questions before you hire an agent to buy your first home or sell and upgrade to more space.
CHICAGO REAL ESTATE AGENTTOP CHICAGO REALTORREALTOR NEAR ME CHICAGOFIRST-TIME HOMEBUYER AGENT CHICAGOLISTING AGENT CHICAGOLAKEVIEW REALTORLINCOLN PARK REALTOR
Matt Ayo
11/4/20264 min read


How to Choose the Best Realtor in Chicago: 10 Questions to Ask Before You Hire
If you typed "best realtor in Chicago" or "realtor near me" into Google, you probably saw hundreds of names, ads, and review sites. Every agent says they are the best. So how do you actually choose the right Chicago real estate agent for buying your first home, or for selling your current place and upgrading to something bigger?
The answer is to interview agents like you would interview anyone you are trusting with your biggest financial decision. Here are the 10 questions I would ask if I were hiring a realtor, and the answers you should expect to hear.
1. How many clients like me have you helped in the last year?
Volume alone does not make an agent great, but experience with your exact situation does. A first-time buyer needs an agent who will explain every step without rushing. A move-up seller needs someone who can coordinate a sale and a purchase at the same time. Ask for specifics: how many first-time buyers, how many buy-and-sell clients, and in which neighborhoods.
2. Which Chicago neighborhoods do you know best?
Chicago is a city of neighborhoods, and each one behaves like its own market. A two-bedroom condo in Lakeview, a single-family home in Roscoe Village, and a new-construction duplex in Bucktown all price differently. The best realtor for you knows the streets, buildings, school boundaries, and recent sales in the areas you are considering. I focus on Lakeview, Lincoln Park, Bucktown, Wicker Park, Logan Square, and the West Loop, plus the surrounding North Side neighborhoods.
3. How will you help me win in a competitive market?
Good homes in popular Chicago neighborhoods can draw multiple offers. Your agent should have a clear strategy: getting fully preapproved before touring, writing clean offers, using escalation clauses wisely, and building relationships with listing agents so your offer gets taken seriously. Many deals are won before the offer is written, simply because the listing agent trusts the buyer's agent to close.
4. What is your marketing plan for my home?
If you are selling, ask to see the plan in writing. At a minimum, it should include professional photography, a pricing strategy based on real comps, MLS exposure, and targeted social media. The best listing agents go further, with video, floor plans, pre-marketing to their network, and staging advice. On the Ben Lalez Team at Compass, my listings get the reach of a large team and brokerage plus a personal social media presence through @ayokeepsitreal.
5. How do you price a home?
Watch out for any agent who quotes a high number just to win your listing. Overpricing often leads to more days on market and price drops that cost sellers money. A good agent will show you recent closed sales, active competition, and absorption rates, then recommend a price that attracts strong buyers quickly.
6. Can you help me sell and buy at the same time?
This is essential for anyone who has outgrown their space. Ask how the agent handles timing, rent-back agreements, contingencies, and lining up closings. An agent who handles both sides of your move can keep the full picture in mind instead of treating your sale and purchase as two separate jobs.
7. Who else will I be working with?
In Illinois, most residential deals involve a real estate attorney, a lender, an inspector, and a title company. Your agent's network matters. Ask who they recommend and why. A responsive attorney and a reliable lender can be the difference between closing on time and losing the home.
8. How do you communicate, and how quickly do you respond?
Real estate moves fast. When a new listing hits the market on a Thursday, you want an agent who is calling you that day, not next week. Ask how they prefer to communicate, text, phone, or email, and how quickly you can expect replies during evenings and weekends.
9. How are you paid, and what does the buyer agency agreement say?
Since 2024, buyers in Chicago and across the country sign a written agreement with their agent before touring homes. A good agent will walk you through it clearly, including how compensation works and how long the agreement lasts. If an agent cannot explain it simply, keep looking. I wrote a full guide on buyer agency agreements in Chicago if you want the details.
10. Can I talk to past clients or read your reviews?
Reviews on Google and Zillow, testimonials, and case studies tell you how an agent treats people when things get stressful. Look for patterns: communication, negotiation, and how they handled problems. Recognition from peers helps too. I am honored to hold a Top Producer Award from the Chicago Association of Realtors and to have been named to Chicago Agent Magazine's 2026 Who's Who in Chicagoland Real Estate.
Red flags when hiring a Chicago real estate agent
They push you to make decisions before you feel ready
They do not know the neighborhood you want to buy in
They suggest a list price far above what the comps support
They are hard to reach during your interview
They cannot explain fees, contracts, or attorney review in plain language
Frequently asked questions
Do I need a realtor to buy a house in Chicago? It is not legally required, but a buyer's agent helps you find homes, negotiate price and credits, and manage inspections, attorney review, and closing. For first-time buyers especially, that guidance can save thousands.
Should I use the same agent to buy and sell? In most cases, yes. One agent coordinating both transactions makes timing, negotiation, and communication much simpler.
How do I find a realtor near me in Chicago? Search for agents who specialize in your neighborhood, read their reviews and blog content, and interview at least two before you sign anything.
Let's see if we're a good fit
Whether you are buying your first home or selling to upgrade to more space, I would love to talk through your goals. There is no pressure and no obligation, just a clear plan and honest advice. Book a free consultation with Matt Ayo, and follow @ayokeepsitreal on Instagram for real talk about Chicago real estate.



