Buying Your First Home in Chicago: A Complete Guide with Matt Ayo

Buying a home in Chicago is an exhilarating and rewarding experience—but at times, it can also feel overwhelming. As a first-time homebuyer, you need more than just access to listings. You need a trusted guide—someone who will advocate for you, simplify the process, and always keep your best interests front and center.

Matt Ayo is one of Chicago’s trusted real estate professionals at Compass, and helping first-time buyers confidently navigate the Chicago market has become a core focus of his work. Matt’s approach is rooted in education, strategy, and relationship-building—ensuring his clients not only find the right home, but make smart, informed decisions along the way.

Drawing on years of experience, market insight, and finely tuned instincts, Matt guides first-time buyers through every step of the process: exploring neighborhoods, selecting properties, negotiating contracts, and coordinating with lenders, inspectors, and attorneys to reach the closing table smoothly. He takes the time to truly understand his clients’ goals, lifestyle, and priorities—becoming a vested partner in helping them achieve long-term real estate success.

“I love working with clients who are entering the market for the first time. Helping someone discover the neighborhood and home that truly fits their life is incredibly rewarding,” Matt shares.

Top Questions from First-Time Homebuyers in Chicago

1. How do I know when to buy versus keep renting?

To determine whether buying makes more sense than renting, compare what you’re currently paying in rent to what your all-in monthly ownership cost would be. That includes:

• Mortgage payment

• HOA (condo assessment) fees

• Property taxes

• Minus potential tax deductions for mortgage interest and property taxes

Let’s look at an example in Chicago:

• Monthly rent: $2,500

• Purchase price: $400,000 condo (yes—this is very realistic in Chicago)

To purchase a $400,000 condo, you’d need approximately $50,000 to cover your down payment and closing costs. With a $350,000 mortgage, your estimated monthly costs might look like this:

• Mortgage & mortgage insurance: $1,867

• HOA fees: $350

• Property taxes: $400

• Total: $2,617/month

That’s roughly $100 more than rent—but with ownership, you benefit from tax deductions, long-term appreciation, and equity growth. When you sell, you recapture value. Rent, on the other hand, is money you never see again.

Considering that Chicago rents have increased an average of 5%+ annually over the past decade, buying is often a smart long-term financial move.

2. How much house can I afford?

One of the most important steps in the homebuying process is securing the right mortgage—and choosing the right lender matters just as much as choosing the right agent.

As part of his service at Compass, Matt Ayo introduces clients to some of Chicago’s top-performing, reliable mortgage lenders. If you’re buying your first home, getting pre-approved early gives you a clear understanding of your purchasing power and prevents disappointment later in the process.

A common rule of thumb is that up to 35% of your gross monthly income can go toward housing costs. Your final purchase price will depend on:

• Interest rates

• Property taxes

• HOA fees

• Loan structure

There are a lot of moving pieces—but this is exactly where an experienced Chicago buyer’s agent makes the process manageable.

3. Do I have to get pre-approved for a mortgage?

In a competitive market like Chicago, yes—pre-approval is strongly recommended.

A true pre-approval from a reputable lender (not just a basic pre-qualification) strengthens your offer and shows sellers you’re serious and financially vetted. While interest rates matter, responsiveness, reliability, and the ability to close on time matter even more—especially for first-time buyers who want fewer surprises and smoother transactions.

I have several preferred lenders that i work with that i'm happy to make a warm introduction to!

4. What is a buyer’s agent, and why do I need one?

Just as sellers have representation, buyers deserve a professional advocate on their side. A buyer’s agent is a licensed real estate professional whose sole responsibility is protecting your interests.

Your first home purchase involves many professionals—attorneys, inspectors, lenders—and your buyer’s agent is the quarterback coordinating them all. From showings to closing, your agent ensures timelines are met, contingencies are protected, and risks are minimized.

A strong buyer’s agent will:

• Help you identify the best neighborhoods for your lifestyle and budget

• Find and secure the right properties (often before they hit the market)

• Negotiate aggressively on your behalf

• Guide you through attorney review, inspections, and financing

• Keep you informed, confident, and protected every step of the way

In short: your buyer’s agent is your advocate, strategist, and guide.

Top Tips for First-Time Homebuyers

• Set priorities early. Decide what matters most—location, space, or finishes—before you start touring homes. This clarity helps prevent buyer’s remorse.

• Understand the full cost of ownership. Beyond your mortgage, budget for taxes, insurance, HOA fees, and maintenance.

• Research school districts—even if you don’t have kids. Strong school districts often support long-term property value and neighborhood stability.

• Always include an inspection contingency. A thorough inspection can uncover material defects or deferred maintenance. During attorney review, you may request repairs or credits.

Ready to Buy Your First Home in Chicago?

If you’re ready to take the next step toward homeownership, working with the right agent makes all the difference.

“I can’t recommend Matt Ayo enough for buyers who want a knowledgeable, trustworthy, and professional advocate. He’s more than an agent—he’s a true consultant who looks out for your best interests.” — Past Buyer

Contact Matt Ayo today and let’s find your dream home in Chicago.

T: 312-826-2104

© 2026. All rights reserved.

E: matt@mattayorealtor.com